Expert Round-Up Topic: Why Did You Choose Traditional, Hybrid, or Self-Publishing, and What Would You Choose Now?
MIMI SMITH
I love this question because believe it or not, there is a misconception that self-publishers exist because they could not secure a traditional publishing deal, and that’s not true at all. Many exist because self-publishing offers greater autonomy and control. It gives the freedom to write what you want to write, and the market doesn’t dictate the subject. Everyone has their reader. We were willing to find our readers. Most importantly, if I choose not to write anymore, then I simply won’t write anymore. I am not bound to a traditional publishing agreement. Currently, I am self-published, as well as the founder and publisher of a children’s publishing company.
Many books that are self-published are equal in quality to traditionally published books. Another benefit of self-publishing is that we are our own competition, because we don’t have to be mindful of a bigger author’s launch date. We simply launch and our books will find their readers, and they usually do.
Self-publishers also proceed at their own pace. They write when they want to write and they are done when they say they are done. As a company that’s only seven months old, we have already published eight books in total, five of which are available in digital format. Multiple literary awards and positive professional reviews. A few of our books are also currently cataloged with public libraries and elementary schools. So, if I knew what I knew now, would I do it again? Absolutely, without hesitation.
Dr. Mimi Smith is an author and the founder and CEO of Books for Little Hearts™.
https://booksforlittlehearts.carrd.co/
LORRIE THOMAS
I wrote the 36-Hour Course to Online Marketing with McGraw Hill in 2010. As a former UC Santa Barbara and UC Berkeley professor and agency owner, I had always wanted to write a book and wasn’t sure how to go about it. When I was approached by McGraw Hill, I knew it was a sign and would be the perfect match. I was an educator, they specialized in educational books, and they specialized in publishing and held me accountable.
As a busines owner, it’s easy when you run a business to focus on serving clients, supporting clients and getting caught up in the day to day. While self-publishing could have made me more per book, I wanted to collaborate with an established publishing house who knew the ins and outs and had clear, established processes. I was so happy I did. They were absolutely wonderful to work with from start to finish.
Lorrie Thomas is the author of 36-Hour Course to Online Marketing and the CEO of Web Marketing Therapy®.
https://webmarketingtherapy.com/
JOBERT E. ABUEVA
After starting with the literary agent route, which offered a lot of positive feedback yet no representation, I had the good fortune of publishing my first book, Boy Wander: A Coming of Age Memoir, through a traditional independent publisher, Rattling Good Yarns Press. I had pitched directly to them at a writer’s conference. When it came to my second book, The Janus Plan: A No-Resolutions Path to Begin Your Year with Intention, I first thought I would start my own imprint and self-publish but soon realized it was a heavy lift while still holding down a day job. That is when I turned to hybrid publishing and landed with Weaving Influence Press. Going hybrid enabled me to tap into folks with publishing experience and expertise. They know the pitfalls that we authors tend to miss, such as not including endnotes to back up research. It was also easier to have a dialogue on the book’s look and feel. Also, as a marketer, I love plotting the strategy behind building awareness and conversion among book buyers, though it isn’t for everyone. The good news is that you can hire support if you can set a budget aside for it.
My advice to fellow authors is to know what matters most to you in terms of speed to market and how much control you would like to have in the process. It sure isn’t one size fits all. Today, I would consider hybrid first as I don’t want to be subject to the long cycle and vagaries of the traditional publishing world. But be sure you understand the terms of your agreement and that you ultimately maintain the rights to your work. That said, I will always hold onto the dream of being represented by a literary agent and having a traditional publisher come through.
Jobert E. Abueva is the author of Boy Wander: A Coming of Age Memoir and The Janus Plan: A No-Resolutions Path to Begin Your Year with Intention, a TEDx speaker, and principal of Javelin Arc LLC, a leadership and marketing consultancy.
MOSHE COHEN
I’ve written three books so far and self-published all of them for the following reasons: timing, editorial control, and cost-benefit. By the time I was ready to publish my first book, I’d been working on it for over six years, and when I spoke to publishers, they indicated it would take another eighteen months for the book to go to print. At that point, I didn’t want to wait that long, and by self-publishing, I was able to have it in stores within four months.
A second consideration was that I wanted to make the editorial decisions in the publishing process on my own. While I had no fewer than four experienced writers and academics review and edit my manuscripts, and I was grateful to have their input, none of them had veto power or decision-making authority over the final version. At the advice of one of my editors, I cut down the manuscript by twenty-five percent, which was very painful, but no one other than me had the power to decide what to cut.
Finally, traditional publishers take a considerable portion of the profits from the books they publish, and in return help authors market their books to a greater or lesser degree. My sense was that the marketing help I would get for my book would be small compared to the value I’d be giving up. In addition, having run a business for a long time, I was comfortable with my own ability to market my book and was willing to take the risk of going it alone. At this point, having done it once successfully, I followed the same patten for my next two books.
Moshe Cohen is the author of Collywobbles: How to Negotiate When Negotiating Makes You Nervous, Optimism is a Choice and Other Timeless Ideas, and The Optimistic Pessimist: More Timeless Ideas and the founder and president of The Negotiating Table, Inc.
SRI KAZA
My book, Unconvention: A Business Strategy Guide, was published by Ideapress Publishing. I chose to work with an indie publisher rather than self-publish, for credibility.
My intent overall was to get more people to read it – and I felt a publisher would have the tools and skills to help me get better reach.
I wrote the original manuscript while also doing my day job as the CEO of a fintech. I wanted professional editing, cover design and interior design handled by people who do it every day.
Also, the book makes a case about how small businesses outcompete larger rivals. Ideapress and its owner Rohit Bhargava fit the target reader too. Our views were very aligned, and they helped me a lot with visibility and even getting advance praise from the other authors and the former head of the SBA’s Small Business Investment Company.
Mine may be a unique case, but I think the writing process is already a very lonely one – and having a team to work with you to publish and promote is so much more my kind of fun.Â
Sri Kaza is the author of Unconvention: A Business Strategy Guide.
IAN HAWKINS
I’m about to self-publish my second book, Insider Secrets of Professional Speakers. My first book was Insider Secrets of Public Speaking.
With my co-author Nadine Dereza, we chose self-publishing with ReThink for both of these books for the simple reason that we wanted to keep control of the content and design, and having gone a long way down the road with “traditional” publishing, knew that the support from these businesses were not significantly higher than what we could do ourselves with self-publishing.
My personal view is that traditional publishing is great for those who need a sense of validation. As I have a more entrepreneurial mindset, I like investing in a quality product that makes fewer compromises. As a business book from within the industry I write about, it has a genuine grass roots feel with a direct connection to the audience I am trying to reach.
Ian Hawkins is the co-author of Insider Secrets of Professional Speakers and Insider Secrets of Public Speaking.
Insidersecretsofprofessionalspeakers.com (will be live soon)








